Nov. 19, 2005

Walk the Line — Review

Full disclosure: Grace Hill Media offered bloggers a free screening pass in exchange for writing an entry about Serenity; I participated in that offer.

In case you've been living under a rock, Walk the Line is the recent biopic on the country singer Johnny Cash (no, I didn’t really think of him as a “country singer”, either, but that's what I keep reading). Like most music-based movies, there's not much of a plot here — and that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The movie focuses of Cash’s music and, if you like that, you’ll have a good time.

Joaquin Phoenix plays Cash and what I found most fascinating about the performance he performed all the songs himself — there was no dubbing of Cash’s voice over his. If someone had mentioned that to me a month ago, before I had seen the film, that surely would have been a red flag for me since Cash has such an identifiable voice. Still, Phoenix was spot on — several times during the movie I actually closed my eyes for a few seconds and it was like I was listening to a Johnny Cash album.

Admittedly, I have little Cash experience. Sure, I’ve heard clips on tv and in other movies, but I don’t know whether I should be embarrassed that possibly the first time I heard one of his songs uninterrupted was his cover of NiN’s “Hurt”. Dont' get me wrong — I like the track; it’s just that it came out in 2003. The video creeped me out a bit, but that’s mostly because I couldn’t figure out what was going on (the plot of the music video, if you will).

Walk the Line certainly celebrates Cash’s life but it doesn't hold back from his darker times either. Possible spoilers in the rest of this paragraph — if you happen to care about the film’s plot. Among other things, his first marriage was a bit rocky and it was mostly his fault; he lashed out at his wife in anger and cheated on her as well. Then there're the pills. He became addicted to a pill-based drug of some sort (I’m not sure the drug was named) and that certainly did more harm than good, especially in terms of how his drug-induced state put strains on his personal relationships. Basically, Johnny Cash was a jerk.

All the same, Cash has a musicality that’s hard to dislike. The film never goes too many minutes without an excuse to play more of his music (and I’m ok with that). And, if there’re two things that I've realized from this film, it's that I should probably buy some of Cash’s music and it might also be worth adding a few Phoenix flicks to my Netflix queue. Much to the extent of my Cash experience, I hadn’t seen much of Phoenix until now, either (I think Gladiator was his only movie that I had seen). Oh, and I’m open to suggestions on a starter Cash.

This work, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.
10 Responses to “Walk the Line — Review”
  1. Adrian says:

    Johnny Cash isn’t necessarily considered a country singer; or rather, he isn’t considered only a country singer. He always “walked the line” (har har har) between country and rock. He’s one of only a couple people to have been inducted into both the Country and Rock n Roll Hall of Fames.

    As for albums, if you want classic Johnny Cash, Johnny Cash at Folsom Prison or Johnny Cash at San Quentin are absolutely classic. Among the newer stuff, American IV: The Man Comes Around is pretty solid throughout.

  2. Alex says:

    Are both of those — “Johhny Cash at Folson Prison” & “Johnny Cash at San Quentin” — live albums? I like the idea of a classic Johhny Cash album but I find the fidelity of live albums usually pales in comparison to studio works :-/.

  3. Adrian says:

    Yeah, both are live. In this case the energy of the live albums surpases most drawbacks.

  4. Alex says:

    Ah, that’s good to hear. I’ll have to pick one of those up sometime.

  5. wl says:

    whats the name of the song john and june did at the opry that she didnt want to sing because she recorded it with her ex-husband

  6. Josh Baugher says:

    Here’s a good sampler for $8 :-)

    http://www.deepdiscountcd.com/index.cfm?request=cd.cfm?upc=602498843406

  7. Alex says:

    Good thinking, Josh — perhaps I’ll have to pick that up :).

  8. Patrick says:

    Wow, I thought I was sure that most of the musical performances were dubbed vocals. It may have been the theater that I saw the movie in, but some of the music seemed to have a lower grade quality of sound, which made me think that the music was dubbed. Very impressed then!

  9. Urban Saddle » More reasons to like Walk the Line says:

    […] I could have sworn that the musical numbers that Jocquain Phoenix performed in Walk the Line were dubbed. IMDB (thanks Alex) says otherwise. The trivia reports that Phoenix performed all the songs himself and learned guitar from scratch. Impressive! […]

  10. Brenda says:

    This was one of the two BEST movies I have ever seen.The Truman Show was the other. I have seen Walk the Line twice and for some reason I just can’t get it out of my mind. The performances of both Jocquain Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon were truly outstanding. I grew up believing that country music was not cool. I regret my immaturity in that arena and acknowledge that I have missed out on a lot of remarkable music. I am now making up for lost time by having bought the incredible soundtrack . I am afan of Johnny Cash for life. His music though melancholy somehow fills me with a sweet joy.Johnny left a legacy but thanks to Walk The Line and those marvellous actors they now have created a new legacy.

Leave a Reply

HTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>